Open river water beside granite rocks and dry golden grasses in Colorado's high country, with bare willows and a pine-dotted ridge beyond.

Where Lake George Fishes Now That Spinney Is Closed and Eleven Mile Isn't Frozen

November 19, 2026

Eleven Mile is still open water, and it's colder every week. In its last report before the November break, 11 Mile Marina had the water at 49 degrees and the reservoir about 2 to 3 points below 103 percent of capacity. By the marina's count that's still technically full. Both boat ramps are closed for the season. Spinney Mountain's season ended November 15. A few miles up the road, the reservoir most Lake George anglers fish all summer is shut until spring.

That leaves a stretch of a few weeks that's easy to waste. There's not enough ice to stand on and no ramp to back a trailer down. From what the marina and Colorado Parks and Wildlife are reporting, though, fish are still biting along the shore and a kokanee spawning run is underway in the river. The rules and dates for the ice season are already set, so this is the time to get ready for it.

Spinney Won't Reopen for the Ice

CPW lists Spinney Mountain State Park's season as running from spring ice-off "through Nov. 15 annually, unless ice comes on sooner." Freezing over doesn't reopen it, either. The 2026 regulations prohibit ice fishing at Spinney outright and hold trout there to one fish with a 20-inch minimum.

So the next time you can fish Spinney is after the ice goes out in spring. Until then, local anglers who want stillwater have Eleven Mile State Park, and right now it's best fished from shore.

Eleven Mile Is a Shore and Hand-Carry Lake Until It Freezes

CPW's park page says the North Shore and Witcher's Cove ramps are both closed for the season, and only hand-launched, human-powered boats are allowed on the water. The marina's report says the same: canoes, kayaks and float tubes you carry in are still allowed.

Because the water is a couple of points low, the marina points out that your usual spots will be shallower than you remember. For November it recommends spots where deep water comes close to shore. Here's what it reported, species by species:

  • Trout, rated good. Action usually slows once the water drops below 50 degrees. On their last boat trip of the year, marina staff trolled up a lot of 17- to 18-inch cutbows, and Tasmanian Devils worked best. Shore fishing was on and off with nightcrawlers and PowerBait, and Kastmasters and tube jigs were also catching fish from the bank. The marina's top November picks were Rodgers Mountain and Rocking Chair, both places where the bottom drops off deep close to shore. It called Rodgers Mountain "one of the best."
  • Northern pike, rated good. The bite was steady all around the lake, on spoons, tubes and big stickbaits. White lures did well whatever the style. The west end had some great catches, and most of the action was early to late afternoon. Pike were coming from shore as well as from boats.
  • Kokanee, rated poor in the lake. A few 4-year-old fish were being caught here and there.

A few standing Eleven Mile rules still apply from shore. Live minnows are prohibited. Fishing is not allowed inside the buoy line near the dam on the east end, or from islands and docks. Within 100 feet of the inlet mouth, it's flies and lures only, and every fish goes back.

The Kokanee Are in the River Now

The 11 Mile Marina fishing report sums up the kokanee in one line: the river is "chock full of spawners and action is strong." Eleven Mile is one of very few lakes in Colorado stocked with kokanee salmon, according to CPW. Late fall is when those fish leave the reservoir and move up the South Platte to spawn.

The river between the two reservoirs is the stretch anglers call the Dream Stream, and its rules are some of the strictest in the area. The table lists what CPW's regulations allow on each piece of water you're likely to fish through December.

Water What the rules say this winter
Spinney Mountain Reservoir Season ended November 15; ice fishing prohibited; trout limit one fish, 20-inch minimum
South Platte, Spinney outlet to Eleven Mile inlet Artificial flies and lures only; every fish released right away; parts may be closed as posted September 15 to December 31 for kokanee spawning operations
Eleven Mile, within 100 feet of the inlet Flies and lures only; catch and release
Eleven Mile Reservoir Kokanee snagging prohibited; live minnows prohibited; no fishing inside the dam buoy line

The posted closures matter most in practice. Any part of the river can be closed for spawning operations until December 31, so the signs at the water are what decide where you can fish on a given morning. If you'd rather keep a fish this month, trout and pike in the lake are the better bet than kokanee.

The Ice Rules Are Already Set

CPW's Eleven Mile page lists ice fishing as a park activity. For now it says there's no ice on the reservoir, and updates will start again once ice forms. The same section lists the park office number, 719-748-3401. You'll want that number on your phone before the first cold snap that has people walking out from the North Shore.

These rules from CPW's current regulations and 2026 fishing brochure are worth checking against your gear now, before the ice comes in:

  1. Shelters must be portable, according to CPW's regulations for Eleven Mile.
  2. Holes can be no more than 10 inches across in diameter, or on any side, so compare that to the size of your auger blade.
  3. The trout limit is four, and no more than two of them can be over 16 inches.
  4. Yellow perch have no bag or possession limit.
  5. Every vehicle needs a CPW park pass, whatever time of year you visit. CPW lists an individual daily pass at $4 and the Keep Colorado Wild Pass at $29, along with vehicle passes.

The brochure lists its season as March 1, 2026, through March 31, 2027, so those limits cover this whole ice season. Regulations can still change, though. Treat this as general information, not legal advice, and check CPW's current rules before you head out.

The Next Few Dates

Thanksgiving week. 11 Mile Marina's weekly report takes November off and is scheduled to return at Thanksgiving. The marina calls it the only weekly fishing report it knows of for any body of water in Colorado. The first post-break report is the one to read for word on how ice is forming along the shore. Until then, the marina says it has no regular November hours and is open when staff are around working on projects. CPW lists the marina's phone as 719-748-0317.

January 9, February 6 and March 6. These are the three dates for the 2027 Eagle Claw/Shappell Colorado Classic Ice Fishing Tournament, and signup opened November 1. If you want to fish it, signup is already open.

Whenever the ice is ready. You don't need to own a full ice setup to try it. CPW says the marina rents augers, shelters, fish finders and heaters for ice fishing. The marina's guide service also offers a four-hour guided ice trip for two, listed at $325, with a heated shelter and fishing equipment included. The park pass, fishing licenses and gratuity aren't included. It's an easy way to show a visiting relative the lake in January, or to learn the winter spots yourself before you buy gear.

If Eleven Mile hasn't been on your list since summer, our August field guide to Eleven Mile covers the warm-weather version of this lake. The Lake George neighborhood page has more on the town around it.

At Thetford Team Real Estate, we pay attention to what the water's doing out here because a lot of our clients come to Lake George for exactly this. If you're thinking about a cabin within a short drive of the North Shore, or wondering what your place near the reservoir is worth, give us a call. We're always happy to talk about the lake.

Let's Work Together

Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact us today.